Category Archives: Uncategorized

Will Dylan and Bethany be called to testify?

While we should always first and foremost remember the victims in the Idaho 4 tragedy, the two surviving females have garnered a lot of attention over the last six months.

For anyone following the case since news broke on the Nov. 13, 2022 tragedy, the names of survivors Dylan Mortensen (pictured above) and Bethany Funke have come up.

The two were not harmed in the early morning hours of Nov. 13 while three of their roommates and the boyfriend of one of the women were murdered.

If you are at all familiar with the 19-page PAC released a few months back, you know that Mortensen is mentioned as having reportedly seen the suspect on the home’s second floor. While not being able to give a precise description, the Boise resident said she saw a figure clad in black with a mask moving towards her second floor bedroom. The suspect then proceeded to exit the home via the kitchen slider door that leads to the patio. What happened to the suspect from there is not clearly known.

Fast-forward to Dec. 30 in Pennsylvania and arrested and charged with four counts of felony murder and a single count of burglary, alleged killer Bryan Kohberger, 28. Kohberger remains in jail, set to stand trial beginning Oct. 2.

When we get to the trial, it is certainly a possibility that both Mortensen and Funke will be called to testify.

So, will it be the prosecution or the defense calling one or both to testify? As it stands, both sides may want to have one or both women go on the record in front of a jury.

From the prosecution side of things, they hope Mortensen especially can nail down that in fact is was Kohberger she saw that night on the second floor of the home. It has been rumored that the defense may look to call Funke to the stand, claiming she may have some exculpatory information that could possibly clear their client.

You can also figure that the defense will look to have Mortensen get on the stand. They will likely claim that the young woman can’t definitively say under oath it was their client she saw in the home on Nov. 13 right after the murders.

As important as those things are, imagine the possible field day the defense could have with Mortensen for her reported actions (or to some her inactions) over the next 7-8 hours following the killings.

Among the things they may want Mortensen to explain would be:

  • Why did you or Funke wait so long to call 911? Is it possible one or both of you wanted to remove some potentially illegal items such as drugs for instance?
  • Were you under the influence of alcohol or drugs at the time you claim to have seen an individual in the home ultimately making their way to the kitchen slider door? If you were under the influence, how can any of your statements be 100 percent credible?
  • Have you ever done drugs in your life, specifically at 1122 King Road?
  • If you heard crying and whimpering coming from Xana’s room as you indicated, why not go check on her once it was safe to do so?

If you are the prosecution, do you take a chance on calling Mortensen and/or Funke to the stand? It may well be they choose not to.

Meantime, you would have to think the defense team will be chomping at the bit to call both of them.

While you can argue one or both likely did not know their four friends has just been killed, the noises Mortensen reportedly heard should have at least warranted a welfare check on the four when safe to do so.

Buckle up…. I think this trial will be one for the ages when it eventually gets going.

Photo credit: DailyMail

2 Comments

Filed under Uncategorized

Is Kohberger a lone wolf or did he have help?

While the prevailing theory online is that quadruple murder suspect Bryan Kohberger acted alone in the early morning hours of Nov. 13, 2022 at 1122 King Road in Moscow, Idaho, others have different ideas.

The 28-year-old Pennsylvania native remains in jail in Moscow, charged with four felony counts of murder and one felony count of burglary.

Kohberger stands accused of breaking into a home shared by five University of Idaho women at or around 4ish a.m. on Nov. 13. Kohberger is alleged to have killed three of the five females living in the home and the boyfriend of one of the female victims.

As countless people continue mourning the loss of Kaylee Goncalves, Maddie Mogen, Xana Kernodle and Ethan Chapin, onlookers to the case have their focus on a planned Oct. 2 trial date. If Kohberger is found guilty of the murder charges, he could end up getting the death penalty.

So, was the Washington State University criminal justice graduate student allegedly acting alone or did he have help?

My thoughts are the following:

  • How could one individual only as we know to now armed with a knife kill four young, healthy adults? While some or all are thought to have been in some stage of sleep at the time of the incident, it still would take the right kind of attack and timing to pull it off in the span of some 13 or so minutes. While the timeline for the murders has jumped around to some degree, it is generally thought that the suspect acted from approximately 4:05 a.m. to around 4:20 ish a.m. If the suspect had a gun instead of a knife, it seems much more plausible to kill so effectively and quickly, but he did not to the best information we have.
  • How would the individual know who was sleeping where in the six-bedroom home? This is where I begin to wonder if the suspect had some help. Could someone out to get one or more of the roommates tipped off the suspect? That is who was sleeping where and if they would have anyone staying the night with them?
  • How did the individual leave the home with barely a trace of blood outside the home? If the stabbings were as gruesome as we are led to believe, one would expect a bloody trail from the kitchen slider door all the way out to where the suspect’s vehicle was located. At least from police reports to now, there was no such massive trail of blood. So, could someone have helped the suspect disrobe and then do away with the clothes worn during the attacks?
  • It is not a big secret that 1122 King Road was known as a party house. As such, it is not too far of a stretch to think drugs may have been in the home at times. Could this quadruple homicide been payback for a drug deal gone wrong? Why were two roommates left unharmed? While I am not accusing the two survivors (Dylan and Bethany) of being involved, you do wonder why the suspect did not finish off all potential witnesses.

As the months go by and we arrive at a trial, there will continue to be a lot of speculation.

With that in mind, if I was placing a bet in Vegas, I’d say BK had help to one degree or another.

What do you think happened in those early morning hours at 1122 King Road?

Photo credit: ABC News

1 Comment

Filed under Uncategorized

Do Dylan and Bethany Know More from Nov. 13?

If you have been following the Idaho 4 killings closely, the tragedy that took four University of Idaho students back on Sunday, Nov. 13, 2022, you no doubt have heard the names Dylan and Bethany (pictured first and third L-R in the photo).

Dylan and Bethany are the two young female survivors from that horrific scene that claimed the lives of Kaylee Goncalves, Maddie Mogen, Xana Kernodle and Ethan Chapin. Goncalves and Mogen were found deceased in Mogen’s third floor bedroom, while Kernodle and Chapin were located in the former’s bedroom on the second floor.

The two survivors were home at the time of the event. Dylan reportedly in a second floor bedroom and Bethany on the ground floor.

It is estimated that the event happened somewhere between 4:05 a.m. and 4:20 a.m. Yes, in such a short span of time, four young lives were tragically ended.

So, how is it that Dylan and Bethany escaped with no injuries and lived to tell about it?

Those following the case closely know that a 911 call for the Moscow Police Department was not made until 11:58 a.m. Some 7-8 hours passed from when the tragedy began to when authorities were alerted of a supposed unconscious individual in the home at 1122 King Road (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J_-fAgUSIh8).

We also know from the PCA that was given out a few months back by police that Dylan reportedly saw a figure clad in black and wearing a mask go right past her on the second floor, exiting the home through the kitchen slider door by the patio. Dylan, a Boise resident, was reportedly so frozen that she closed her bedroom door and did not emerge until late that morning.

Okay, how many times have you opened your bedroom around 4:20 ish a.m. and seen a tall, black clothing clad and wearing a mask individual walk by you? I am guessing the response is few to no times. Keep in mind Dylan reportedly opened her bedroom door three times during the 15 minutes or so that the killings were taking place. Dylan reportedly heard noises that included crying and whimpering coming from Kernodle’s room not far from her on the second floor.

Nowhere in the PCA does it mention that Bethany heard or saw anything from her first floor bedroom vantage point. In fact, most assume Bethany slept through it all.

Okay, as a journalist of 30+ years, I have many questions from this. Among them:

  • Why would Dylan not go and knock on Xana’s door after the suspect left the home? Dylan reportedly tried texting different roommates in the home to no avail. Keep in mind that crying and whimpering are two different things. If Dylan heard what she thought was Xana both crying and whimpering, why not go check on her once safe to do so?
  • Why not text and/or go downstairs once safe to do so and get your best friend Bethany up? The two then could have gone to check on Xana together. One would also think checking on the two women on the third floor would be a rationale line of thinking given there appeared to be a stranger in the home at such an odd hour.
  • Why the long delay from when the incident occurred to someone (supposedly Bethany) calling 911? While none of us are privy to the medical examiner’s report, perhaps one or or more of the deceased may have lived had they gotten immediate medical attention. Yes, chances may be slim, but we will not know until more comes out at trial. In fact, much like the tragic Uvalde school shooting in 2022, we may never know here if one or more lives could have been saved if EMT’s were on the scene sooner than later.
  • Finally, is there a chance Dylan and Bethany did not want authorities in the home right away? The home was a well-known party house. Could there have been things in the home that one or more residents would not have wanted police to discover. Trust me, police could care less about drinking and even drugs in a home when there have been four murders.

As we get to an October trial, hopefully we will learn more about what Dylan and Bethany know what really went down those early morning hours at 1122 King Road.

Leave a comment

Filed under Uncategorized

Would you convict B.K. as of today?

As we near the start of summer in a few weeks. we’re still many months away from a trial in the murder of four University of Idaho students last Nov. 13 in Moscow.

If you take the time to go online and do some searches of different keyword terms (Idaho4) for example, you will find many stories, videos, pictures, podcasts and so on related to the horror that went down in the early morning hours that Sunday less than two weeks before Thanksgiving.

That said, both the prosecution and defense have targeted Oct. 2 of this year as a date for what could be a six or so week trial to begin.

So, if there were a trial today and you were presented with the evidence we have so far, would you convict the suspect Bryan Kohberger?

If I was sitting on that Idaho jury (be it near where the murders took place or even another county if the trial were to be moved), I would not say this is a slam dunk case by any means.

Yes, DNA is going to be one of if not the big keys in this upcoming trial. That said, you can bet the defense as in the trial of the century nearly 30 years ago (O.J. Simpson) will have their own DNA experts called to testify. If you look at other things such as the suspect’s cell phone activity, driving through the neighborhood on King Road numerous times etc. one would say the state has a strong case.

With that in mind, I still think we will get a plot twist or two once the state has to show all its cards at trial. Could that be a witness (other than Dylan), computer hard drive evidence etc. that could put the final nail in B.K.’s coffin?

As I will note in a future post, I’m not 100 percent convinced at least one more person wasn’t involved in this horrific quadruple murder. For a single person to go into a strange home at 4 ish in the morning and murder four young adults in a span of 13 or so minutes is close to a superhuman accomplishment. Having one or more others involved would make it much easier to carry out. Then again, could additional individuals all manage to keep things quiet, not rat on one another etc.?

As of today, I do not think the State of Idaho has enough with what the public knows now to get a unanimous conviction. Remember, it just takes one juror out of 12 to mess up a conviction.

The state will come forward with more at trial and it will need it to get a unanimous conviction.

Leave a comment

Filed under Uncategorized

How vulnerable was the home on King Road?

What made 1122 King Road stand out to a killer?

When you stand outside the property and walk around it, nothing stands out of note.

Having seen the house in person Memorial Day weekend, I was amazed at how much more compact the neighborhood is than what you see on television. Being there in person gives you an even better appreciation of how on top of one another these homes and apartments are.

That said, the home at 1122 had to stand out for some reason to the alleged killer.

Even more perplexing is did this quadruple murder have to take place to begin with?

The prevailing theory is that the killer entered the home from the kitchen patio door on what is considered the second floor of the three-story residence. It is also reported from one of the two surviving roommates that the killer left the home through that same sliding door.

While it is easy to be a Monday morning quarterback, there were several deficiencies that made the residents at 1122 more vulnerable.

The most glaring one to me was the fact that the patio was accessible to anyone who wanted to go there.

Imagine for a moment if that patio had been surrounded by a big gate and/or fence. Yes, the killer may well had still be able to get in. That said, a big gate/fence surrounding the patio outside the kitchen door would have made it much more challenging. Also, think about how security cameras may have led a killer to think twice about entering. The individual who owned the home at the time of the killings has since given the property to the University of Idaho. It is now boarded up and much more difficult for someone to break in (there is also security there 24/7 now).

We also do not know if the residents (Kaylee, Maddie, Xana, Bethany, Dylan) locked the doors on a regular basis. If they did not, this would have made it so much easier for the killer to come in.

Let’s be honest…. it is Moscow, Idaho and not Chicago or Los Angeles. You’re not expecting to have a quadruple homicide in a town of some 25,000 people. As such, it would not be terribly uncommon for many people to not lock their doors and windows in this quaint little college town.

The old adage that a killer will do whatever it takes to kill is true. Even better security at 1122 King Road may not have prevented this tragedy.

At the end of the day, however, that home was vulnerable as were its occupants on that fateful Nov. 13 morning.

Leave a comment

Filed under Uncategorized

Seeing 1122 King Road in person

Seeing 1122 King Road in person was surreal, sad and a number of other emotions. It certainly made it hit home a lot closer. I would say the only similar experience would have been when I went to the Gulf Coast as a reporter shortly after Hurricane Katrina. While seeing the damage brought by Katrina on CNN etc. was quite an impact for sure, seeing it with your own eyes was 10 times greater.

I made sure during my visit to the outside of 1122 King Road last weekend to be respectful and not make the job difficult for security on hand. Part of going there along with my journalist curiosity was to lay flowers and a note at the small memorial in the front of the driveway.

Hopefully Ethan, Xana, Kaylee and Maddie knew how many people cared about them.

Leave a comment

Filed under Uncategorized

Death on King Road

As a journalist of more than 30 years, I have followed countless crime cases. That is both for reporting on and out of personal interest. The tragic killing of 4 University of Idaho students last Nov. 13 (2022) has stayed with me through now. My goal with this blog is to keep readers up to speed on the latest happenings, present some theories, and engage with readers. Most importantly, I want to see justice prevail for Kaylee, Maddie, Xana and Ethan.

Leave a comment

Filed under Uncategorized

Hello world!

Welcome to WordPress.com! This is your very first post. Click the Edit link to modify or delete it, or start a new post. If you like, use this post to tell readers why you started this blog and what you plan to do with it.

Happy blogging!

1 Comment

Filed under Uncategorized